If We Were Giants
by Dave Matthews, Clete Barrett SmithPublished by: Disney-Hyperion on March 3, 2020
Genres: Fantasy, Middle Grade
Pages: 304
Format: Hardcover
Source: Disney-Hyperion
Rating:
Kirra, a curious, agile, and outgoing girl, lives in an idyllic community hidden inside a dormant volcano. She and her father are the only two people allowed to venture beyond its walls. Kirra is in training to become a Storyteller like him, and together they travel from village to village spreading fearsome tales designed to keep outsiders away from their secret nest. One day, after hearing rumors of strangers called the "Takers," Kirra leaves the volcano by herself, hoping to discover her own story. But she unknowingly leads the Takers back to her doorstep, and they rob her of everything she has ever held dear. A devastated Kirra is found by a boy named Luwan and adopted into his family, which lives among others high in the trees of a dense forest. Now quiet and withdrawn, Kirra hides her dark past from everyone and never wants to leave the safety of her tree dwelling. Luwan, on the other hand, loves to explore. One day it leads to trouble: He is captured while spying on a group of strangers. The Takers have returned. To save the Tree Folk, Kirra must face her inner demons and summon all her storytelling to weave the most important tale of her life. This compelling novel about overcoming loss, embracing community, and living in harmony with nature is highlighted with a full-color insert of concept artwork, making it perfect for family sharing.
Many thanks to RockStar Book Tour and Disney-Hyperion for a finished copy in exchange for an honest, unbiased review.
When I saw this was co-written by Dave Matthews, I figured it was a Dave Matthews, not the Dave Matthews.
It’s not often that I’m happy to be wrong, but this was definitely one of those times. In fact, if you get a chance to listen to an interview with the authors, any interview really, it’s actually a really fun and interesting backstory as to how the book came to exist. Especially considering you wouldn’t necessarily expect a fantasy book from a well-known musician. Yet, here we are. And it just works.
If We Were Giants is a gorgeous coming-of-age tale of a young girl with PTSD who learns to overcome her fear of the past to embrace the possibility of a new future. Guaranteed to unravel a few heartstrings along the way.
I was honestly expecting a little more action going into this, and there was some, but where the book really shines is the struggle and growth in the characters. The message of the story was every bit as beautiful as the world that Matthews and Smith paint. I for sure wouldn’t mind a visit there. Then again, this isn’t quite the type of book I normally I read, and Stabby McStabbyPants here would have absolutely no qualms defending my forest in a much more pointy and traditional way. Sure, not as creative as the folks in the book, but it gets the job done, just the same.
❧ I normally tend not to read author’s notes (because I’m a monster, obviously), but I’m glad I read this one. Wow, I feel seen.
What both authors have in common is that when they were children, they often explored in the woods and imagined hidden civilizations there, stumbling upon the unknown, or creating elaborate stories in their minds. In fact, in Dave Matthews’ note, as a kid in New York, he would play in the woods and imagine finding secret communities. As a child, also in New York, I did the same exact thing … except with dragons. Yes, I expected to find dragons in the woods. This should come as no surprise, really. Although why they’d be in the woods, I haven’t a clue, because forest + fire = horrible idea.
Man, I got such a rush of nostalgia just reading that note, and I want to start with that, because it’s such a universal experience, I think, as a rural or even semi-rural kid.
❧ The story opens on Kirra’s father, a storyteller, and Kirra learning to follow in his footsteps, and the narrative unfolds as Kirra finds the strength to tell her own story.
This was such a freaking powerful thing. I’ve always been a fan of this sort of structure, especially since when you come from a broken background, telling your story is freaking hard. It takes courage and strength and all sorts of things that are difficult to discover in yourself, and Kirra is no exception.
This is definitely more of a character-driven book, and the plot sometimes feels absent or takes a back seat to the character growth.
I do like how the arc turned out in the end. It was a bit slow in some places getting there, but the ride was worth it, and there was a definite payoff. It isn’t just Kirra, though. A lot of the other kids, and heck even adults, learn to find themselves along the way, and that was fabulous to see, too.
Kirra, she answered in her head. Was that still her name? Did you actually have a name if everyone who knew it was gone?
❧ This story is chock full of amazing kids doing amazing things … but most of all, being able to dream big.
Middle grade is rife with books where kids save the day, as you might expect, and this is no exception. But gosh was it so easy to root for these kids. What I loved about this is that these kids don’t have superpowers or magic or anything like that. So what do they use to save their people? Their brains. What an amazing thing.
Even more than that, the kids end up being empowered to just do the things they love, and once they embrace that, the saving the day part becomes so much easier.
I loved the message of this, especially since one of the most crucial kids to the plot is an inventor/tinkerer/engineer, and a female, which is something I feel like kids need to see more of.
“Oh, yes.”
“Big trouble?”
“The biggest.”
Tiko sighed. “Okay, then. I guess it’s a good idea for me to go play with Derain and Miki. Might be the last time I see them for a while.”
❧ In this, Kirra suffers from PTSD and panic attacks, and I thought this was handled in a very thoughtful manner.
Mostly, Kirra practices avoidance, staying away from what she calls Memory Traps—things that evoke a strong reminder of her family or anything that happened previously. When she can’t avoid the Memory Traps, though, she has a major panic attack. While I have experience with neither, so I can’t really comment on how true they are to real life, I appreciated the recognition of Kirra’s trauma and her familiar avoidance patterns.
A Memory Trap could suck her in like a whirlpool and force her to spin backward. Back to Before. And then her mind, dragging her heart along with it, would end up in a very bad place.
❧ There are so many poignant lessons in this that can bridge into some really important discussions with middle-grade readers.
I would even suggest it’d make for a good classroom or group read, to launch into some discussion points. The lessons in it are fairly universal, too. Here’s just a small snippet of them:
✿ Overcoming trauma
✿ The Takers (taking more than you should, from both others and nature)
✿ Community and working together
✿ Following dreams
✿ Learning to speak up
✿ Ingenuity and teamwork > brute strength
✿ Storytelling as a tool for change
As I was reading, it was just so easy to see where some amazing discussions could be had, and I was actually curious about a mid-grader’s point of view on some of the events.
❧ This is totally a me thing, but ugh, open endings in standalones drive me bonkers.
I’m a nosy little onion who wants to know what happens next, dang it. I want a clean break, especially with a standalone, since I know this will be the one and only time I get to fall into this world, and I don’t want that incessant niggling of, well, what’s next? There is no next. That’s it. You have to fill in the rest of the blanks yourself.
Some people love open endings, and if you do, this ending will work really well for you, because the implications were amazing and there’s so much that can be done with them. It’s just really not my thing.
Week One:
3/2/2020 Nay’s Pink Bookshelf Review
3/3/2020 Feed Your Fiction Addiction Review
3/4/2020 Lifestyle of Me Review
3/5/2020 She Just Loves Books Review
3/6/2020 Hurn Publications Review
Week Two:
3/9/2020 The Writerly Way Review
3/10/2020 BookHounds YA Review
3/11/2020 Two Chicks on Books Excerpt
3/12/2020 Turning the Pages Review
3/13/2020 Log Cabin Library Review
Week Three:
3/16/2020 Word Spelunking Excerpt
3/17/2020 fictitious.fox Review
3/18/2020 My Quirky Writing Review
3/19/2020 Little Red Reads Review
3/20/2020 Locks, Hooks, and Books Review
Week Four:
3/23/2020 Fyrekatz Blog Review
3/24/2020 BookHounds Excerpt
3/25/2020 momfluenster Review
3/26/2020 Savings in Seconds Review
3/27/2020 PopTheButterfly Review
Week Five:
3/30/2020 Twirling Book Princess Excerpt
3/31/2020 Two Points of interest Review
Three lucky winners will receive a finished copy of IF WE WERE GIANTS, US Only.
a Rafflecopter giveaway
This sounds like an absolute delightful book, and one to recommend to one or more of my nieces. ☺️
I definitely think it’d be a great book for young girls!
Wait, Dave Matthews wrote a book?? How cool, and it sounds like he did a pretty good job😁
Tammy @ Books, Bones & Buffy recently posted…Blog Tour Giveaway: RE-COIL by J.T. Nicholas
Technically, he co-wrote a book. He seems to have come up with the idea/plot and Clete Barrett Smith wrote the words. 🙂 I thought it was super neat, though! Definitely better than you’d think it’d be if someone said, “Oh yeah, this random musician wrote a book.” xD
What a great review and when I saw the book, I immediately thought it couldn’t possibly being THE Dave Matthews. How cool and thanks for clearing it up early 🙂 I also really like the cover. I am finding lots of cool MG reads here lately.
So I’m going to go hide out in spam now until you find me 🙂
Barb @ Booker T’s Farm recently posted…Why Am I Drawn To This Series??? – The Maple Murders Review
Yes! Isn’t that exciting? I grew up listening to Dave Matthews, so it caught my attention. MG books have the greatest covers. Adult artists need to take a page from their book. Bright, vivid colors, something whimsical, a full cover with a lovely background, etc. Adults like fun things, too, I swear!
I FOUND YOU. TAG, YOU’RE IT.
Great review! I used to listen to so much Dave Matthews Band, so I would read this book just for him.
Kristi @ConfessionsofaYAReader recently posted…2000 Follower Giveaway
Me, too, which is why I thought surely it wasn’t him. xD But yup!