Let’s Talk Bookish is a weekly meme, hosted by Rukky @ Eternity Books & Dani @ Literary Lion, where we discuss certain topics, share our opinions, and spread the love by visiting each other’s posts. It’s supposed to be posted on Friday, but being on time is hard and it’s better late than never.
This week’s topic is a freebie, so I wanted to discuss the #ownvoices tag and where it fits into fantasy, which is the genre I read the most and absolutely love.
I thought I knew what #ownvoices meant, but there’s been some pushback lately from authors that has given me pause and made me stop to think about how we tag #ownvoices works. Particularly, for me, this tweet started it all:
Hmmm…I see the #ownvoices hashtag is being used for BLACK SUN but FYI it’s epic Fantasy set in imaginary places that yes, are inspired by Pre-Columbian Americas but no, it is not #ownvoices, any more than European-inspired epic Fantasy is #ownvoices for white authors.
— Rebecca Roanhorse mostly on hiatus (@RoanhorseBex) July 10, 2020
This is a pretty big discussion to tackle, so let’s start small, with what #ownvoices even means in the first place.
What does #ownvoices mean?
#Ownvoices was coined by Corinne Duyvis in 2015. She made a tweet, struck with inspiration, and wham, a movement was born. Little did she know, I’m sure. Or maybe she did. I dunno. She could be a time traveler. I’m not judging.
#ownvoices, to recommend kidlit about diverse characters written by authors from that same diverse group.
— Corinne Duyvis (@corinneduyvis) September 6, 2015
In its original context, it’s a term meant to describe the situation where a character and an author share a marginalized identity. Mostly with the intent that the identity is properly represented in a meaningful way that may not occur with authors writing about marginalized identities they don’t share. In other words, it’s a more personal look at what it’s like to live as/with [insert identity trait].
So where does #ownvoices fit in fantasy?
This is a bit of a sticky issue. I mean, in pretty much every other genre, it’s easy to see where it fits, right? It takes place in the real world, so obviously, these identities influence the characters in a real, applicable way that happens in a fictional Earth that looks enough like the real one where it makes sense, yeah?
Okay, but what about when you throw in superheroes? Or orcs? Or dragons? Or a world that’s not even reminiscent of Earth with all of the above and talking swords and gods and magic? Can, or even should, these books still be considered #ownvoices if the authors aren’t staff-wielding necromancers attempting to overthrow the Great Evil? (And if they are … call me. We should talk.)
The answer I’m going with is it’s complicated but also, yeah, if the author says it is, then probably so.
There are some situations in fantasy where it’s easy to tell where the #ownvoices comes into play—like if it’s a disability, for example. That’s translatable to almost any world, and sometimes changing the world means presenting the disability in a new light, such as the way Deeplight changes up the game on deafness. When it comes to fantasy worlds, though, the waters get a little muddier.
What about fantasy worlds based on marginalized cultures?
The lines tend to blur when we’re talking about worlds that are completely fabricated, but clearly based on a particular culture. Should these be considered #ownvoices?
Again, I’d be inclined to revert back to the author and what their intention was. There are fabulous worlds that expand on marginalized cultures, and that’s the point of them. It emphasizes cultures and beliefs, right down to sometimes food and language, except in a different world setting. However, it’s still recognizable by its real-world influence, and when it’s written by a person from that culture, it seems clear that it should be considered #ownvoices, as it’s a glimpse into a culture (albeit shrouded in fantasy) that is enriched by the author being a member of that group.
I would even go so far as to argue that any person writing about their culture could be considered #ownvoices, to a certain extent, when it’s clear that it’s a unique voice pushing a particular culture.
As Rebecca Roanhorse points out, there’s a lot of European-inspired epic fantasy, where the cultures become a conglomerate mush, and that probably wouldn’t qualify. But what about an Irish author writing about Celtic mythology and weaving in lore and language? I would absolutely consider that #ownvoices, myself.
For me, personally, the #ownvoices tag is all about calling attention to a culture or condition that is underrepresented in mainstream books in general.
The benefit, of course, is getting to read about a genuine, accurate portrayal of the author’s experience of their own culture/identity, and that in and itself is powerful, whatever form it takes.
But do marginalized authors *HAVE* to write #ownvoices stories?
I feel like the answer should obviously be no, of course not, and yet … here we are. Because Rebecca Roanhorse raised a fantastic point further down in her tweet:
From other comments in the thread, I understand the intention is good, but there’s something that feels insidious about it, like we’re not allowed to make stuff up & we can only write anthropological texts of the [insert] experience or something. I don’t care for the tag.
— Rebecca Roanhorse mostly on hiatus (@RoanhorseBex) July 10, 2020
As well-meaning as it may be, I think the bookish community has gotten so caught up on reading diverse and reading #ownvoices that they’ve tended to shoehorn marginalized authors into always writing #ownvoices stories, which isn’t always the author’s intent. Sometimes authors just want to write a world they feel, and it isn’t intended to represent their identity at all.
The big problem here is that it’s often difficult to find authors’ thoughts on whether or not their book is #ownvoices, and sometimes publishers will push the #ownvoices tag for marketing, regardless.
It definitely can muddy the waters. Even as I made the list at the bottom of this post, I had to stop and think, is this book #ownvoices? Would the author consider it as such? I honestly wasn’t sure on some of them, even though I had assumed they were #ownvoices.
Is it realistic to expect every reader/blogger to label books correctly? Probably not. Goodness knows I’m so far from perfect that I can only see it through a telescope late at night. I think it’s going to require a melding of minds, with readers trying to discern whether the author deems it #ownvoices or not, and authors understanding that readers, well-meaning or otherwise, are bound to make mistakes and might need correcting. Or gentle prodding. Sometimes with a cattle prod.
#ownvoices fantasy books I recommend
Because I can never just leave you guys hanging, can I? I would be derelict in my responsibilities. Who’s going to make your TBRs weep if not I? Who’s going to make you question how important sleep is just to catch up? Who’s going to unapologetically throw all the books … okay, wait, that one’s probably all bookish people ever, but you get my point.
Click the cover to go to Goodreads.
TL;DR
#ownvoices is:
- A label for a book written by someone with a marginalized identity featuring a character sharing that identity.
- A well-intended way to uplift marginalized authors and allow them to share their stories.
- Meant to highlight someone writing about a lived identity rather than being written by an author who doesn’t share that identity.
- A call to the bookish community to broaden their horizons and read more diverse books.
#ownvoices is not:
- Foolproof or without its drawbacks and limitations.
- Always an apt title for all books written by marginalized authors.
- A new label to shoehorn marginalized authors into when they make it clear that’s not their intent.
I just love you for being brave and willing to use your platform for taking these complicated topics on. Especially when there are such strong feelings, extreme opinions and loud voices.
susan recently posted…Another Main Character Whose Death Is An… Inconvenience This First Line Friday… Although On Brand For 2020, I Suppose
Thanks! I just think it’s an important conversation for us to have. Especially since, as well-meaning as it may be, it seems to be hurting authors in ways that definitely weren’t intended. 🙂
[…] Sammie @ The Bookwyrm’s Den discusses how the #ownvoices tag fits into fantasy […]
I hadn’t seen that tweet from Rebecca Roanhorse but I’m glad I did because I definitely will NOT be using the hashtag when I write my review of Black Sun! I honestly don’t use it that much anyway, and now I’m intimidated by it and don’t want to offend anyone. Honestly, trying to navigate all the rules of publishing is exhausting sometimes🤣 But I do see that Corinne’s original intention was for it to be a label for “kidlit.” I didn’t know that either! Awesome post, Sammie😁
Tammy @ Books, Bones & Buffy recently posted…Over-Booked [125] – A Book Haul Post
I’m glad I saw it, too, because I would’ve just assumed that Black Sun was OV (and I’m pretty sure I saw it somewhere in marketing before?!). I’m so confused. I’ve been trying to use it in cases where I see the author has used it or spoken about how it’s OV.
I agree. It’s exhausting and daunting and I’m always behind lol.
This post is amazing! And I just found your blog yay!
erin @ Reading On A Star recently posted…Book Review – Lolita by Vladimir Nabokov
Thank you! And welcome to the chaos. Don’t mind the dragons. They don’t bite … much. 😉
I love this to death!! It’s definitely a very complicated topic, but I think it’s amazing you’re talking about it.
Sofia recently posted…A book that might ruin your childhood a little by Kalynn Bayron aka a review of Cinderella is Dead
Thank you! Unfortunately, I feel like I only scratched the surface, but I hadn’t thought of a lot of this or been aware of how some of the authors felt, so I thought it was a discussion we bloggers should definitely keep in mind!
It’s like you knew we needed to hear this before we even said anything. With the recent uprising of the BLM movement, the boom of #ownvoices was incredible. I honestly didn’t even know about this tag until like May or June, and I was wondering deeply about what it really meant.
I think you explained the dilemma with this tag perfectly, and I agree that the waters are a bit murky when it comes to this topic. I feel that if an author presents their work as #ownvoices, and the readers can agree that this author is from a marginalized group and the book represents that marginalized group, then so be it.
I also agree that authors shouldn’t be backed into a corner to be considered #ownvoices just because they come from a marginalized culture/race/group.
Bri @ Books and Shadows recently posted…B+S Book Review: Shielded by KayLynn Flanders
I feel like OV grew so big and suddenly, and with good intentions, that it kind of become a force unto its own. xD
I had never even considered it could be detrimental, because people *want* to read OV books, right? So I loved that this tweet really made me stop and examine not just the tag but my own use of it and whether I was complicit in harming authors and if I needed to be more careful going forward (which of course I do).
Wow you tackled this topic so eloquently! I really appreciate all the points you made and you organized your thoughts so nicely 😄 And can I just say, your graphics are amazing.
Eleanor J. recently posted…Sunshine Blogger Award
Thank you so much! I’m glad you like the graphics. 😀 And I always feel like I ramble horribly, so I’m glad it was easy enough to follow. xD